I usually agree with everything that you say, MP. You know Im your biggest fan
but I don't raise mine for meat and don't sell my eggs for consumption. Not everyone on here does... and our situations are all different. We cannot diagnose someones flock over the internet and I don't think it is our right to suggest they do in the bird without attempting treatment first. We can all agree that, more often than not, we are not dealing with a dangerous virus. I wish more people were responsible with thier housing conditions and thier flock management but that cannot be solved by culling all their birds. Teaching proper sanitary conditions will help, I think.
As for antibiotics creating superbugs and not allowing our flock to fight off infections on their own, I can say the same thing about humans taking antibiotics. I realize later I shouldn't have jumped the gun and treated my hen with antibiotic and cider vinegar would have been good enough to treat her sniffle. I think my birdy was having a rough transition in the dead of winter and got stressed. It irritates me to know that if I would have posted this situation, someone would have told me to kill her. She is absolutely fine now and none of my other birds ever showed signs of illness. We all have the power to deal with our flocks as we see fit but I just think you guys are being way too hasty to jump the gun and cull at every opportunity without considering individual situations.
For you guys, who raise and sell meat birds and eggs, there may be only one option... but for those of us that raise birds just to look pretty in our yards, we have the leisure to cull at our own discretion... after we feel there is no hope.
As for antibiotics creating superbugs and not allowing our flock to fight off infections on their own, I can say the same thing about humans taking antibiotics. I realize later I shouldn't have jumped the gun and treated my hen with antibiotic and cider vinegar would have been good enough to treat her sniffle. I think my birdy was having a rough transition in the dead of winter and got stressed. It irritates me to know that if I would have posted this situation, someone would have told me to kill her. She is absolutely fine now and none of my other birds ever showed signs of illness. We all have the power to deal with our flocks as we see fit but I just think you guys are being way too hasty to jump the gun and cull at every opportunity without considering individual situations.
For you guys, who raise and sell meat birds and eggs, there may be only one option... but for those of us that raise birds just to look pretty in our yards, we have the leisure to cull at our own discretion... after we feel there is no hope.
Last edited: