Quote:
Amen to all that. I am also a hunter, and I am reading this thread wondering where the logic is. The only 2 things that I know of that taint meat (in healthy animals) are
1. Not cleaning properly. It is important to keep the animal clean during processing. Males in any species have scent glands and such that need to be removed cleanly, but most come off with the skinning, or gutting process. So unless it was a messy kill, it shouldn't be a problem. It is VERY important to remove the esophagus in any species.
2. Freezer burn. I think this is the main culprit. Gamey taste is often just freezer burn. Freezer burn tastes terrible!!
Age shouldn't make it taste bad at all, it just isn't as tender. Old bull elk is not as tender as a young bull. Same goes for deer. We take bulls and bucks both during the rut and after as well as young calves or cows in non-antlered hunts. The cow tastes exactly the same as the bull (according to my palate). I wouldn't guess that chickens are much different.
A great remedy to soften older meat is aging the meat. We hang an older dear or elk for up to a week before butchering (well, we have a great processor who does it for us). Slow cooking is another. I slow cook my elk and deer roasts.
An animal that is working for its food is a healthy animal - one we are meant to eat.
My 2 cents.