It looks to me that you are correct. The first is definitely a roo, and the last four appear to be pullets. Is the last one older? She seems to be more mature than the previous three, with more developed comb and wattles. Her overall coloring, and feather shape, would suggest a pullet though. Beautiful birds by the way!Just getting some feedback regarding gender. I'm pretty sure I've got this all nailed down. I'm posting a picture of a roo 1st so you can see
the development. This cockerel is the least developed of the bunch and his gender is obvious.
.
Just want verification that the rest are pullets. This flock is part of our GFF order, 12 weeks old. We are so happy to watch them grow and see the colors coming out.
You think these last 4 are girls?
I would not personally worry about the crest on the dark girl. I have seen MUCH larger crests on SFH. I do personally prefer the smaller crests, but I have some birds with pretty large crests, and I know that everything that was bred here had only one crested parent. I have birds that came from egg swaps that I'm not sure of the parents. I have moved to keeping only non crested roosters because it simplifies housing issues so much. I am not able to free range my birds due to uncontrolled dogs in the area, but I really don't think the hawks and owls would be a problem either unless the entire flock was crested, because it only takes one to give the alarm and everyone takes cover. There will be predation losses no matter what you do. While I have no problem with trimming the feathers (it wont hurt them by the way. Some of the larger flight feathers may bleed a little if cut too close, but those around the face wont), its not something I would do..... and some "landrace" people would consider that "interfering".