" I have worked extensively with two opposing groups in relation to tail angle: the long tailed fowls with their at or below horizontal tail angles and langshan; chabo, and serama with their nearly or fully vertical tail angles. I have also crossed the two groups a great deal and was able to observe a great number of f1, f2, and later generations as well as many backcrosses in both directions. My results point to several conclusions.
First, it seems that the horizontal tail angle is wild type and below horizontal tails are wild type with modification. In some instances, it seems there is a a genetic modification that pushes the wild type tail below the horizontal. The other factor that affects the wildtype tail is the length of the long tailed genetic complex, which pulls the tail to a level below the horizontal. This is a secondary effect rather than a direct effect.
The factors that I consider mutations upon the wild type horizontal tail are the many variations on tail able above horizontal. It would seem that there are several modifiers that can increase the level of vertical orientation of the tail. We see many variations in the exhibition breeds. I cannot say with certainty if we have one mutation or several causing the various levels of vertical orientation. In my experiments, when an extreme high tail is crossed to horizontal or below, the f1 shows tail angles intermediate to the two parent lines at an angle of about 45 degrees. In the f2 nearly all birds showed either horizontal or 45 degree angle, with only a tiny handful (about 10% over many hundreds of birds from such breedings) showing a tail like the high tailed ancestor line. This is very curious. It would suggest that the high tail angle trait is a quantitative trait. The highest tail bred together should show an incremental increase in percentage of high tailed each generation, taking several generations to reach the full expression of nearly vertical tail angle and breed true. However, if one takes a line of birds which breed true for a 45 degree tail angle and raise large numbers, variation in tail angle may never be seen.
When low tailed birds were bred to above horizontal birds (but not the extreme seen in the very high tailed lines), the low tail was very dominant in the f1, but in the f2, the expected 25% above horizontal tails did not emerge. In fact over many years and many crosses of such lines, this result was consistent, and only a small percentage ever went back to the higher end of the above horizontal tail angle. " BRIAN REEDER
In conclusion, the lower tail will overcome the high tail if you select the lower tail offspring to breed to.. Also if your line has a very full tail, it will pull the higher tail angle down when the length gets on the tail.