To Roo or not to Roo... that is the question!

Stephine

Crowing
9 Years
May 30, 2016
1,347
1,261
349
Sonoma
After being attacked by my roo again on the daily (he turns a bit too vigilant every spring and tends to calm down again by mid summer), I am ready to reconsider keeping a rooster with my flock. I have 11 hens at the moment, had 15 at some point. I have always had a rooster. First was a Welsumer (that I ordered) who was too vicious to keep, and a Brahma (an oops, that should have been a hen) that was too big and clumsy for the hens. Then I got a Swedish Flower rooster, which is the one I mentioned in the beginning. He is 4 now.
Apart from being attacked occasionally, which makes caring for the flock a bit trickier, I just can’t halp but wonder if it is the best arrangement for the hens. After looking ready for show in the early spring, half of the flock is starting to look ratty with worn off feathers on the back again. Those are the ones that can’t escape the roo’s attention, because goodness knows they all try to get away. He also doesn’t seem to contribute much to peace keeping in the flock, he seems to periodically single out a hen or two or three for random punishment and harassment. My chickens are free ranging a fair amount, so theoretically his vigilance is an asset, but we had a hawk attack a couple of months ago and the one that did the actual protecting was our dog. Maybe it’s because the hens aren’t particularly listening to his warning calls... But he is unsettled by just about everything (attacking his caretaker when she is getting eggs is a case in point) and gives so many alarm trills, grunts and calls that they might have learned to mainly ignore him.
I do like roosters, because they are gorgeous and I like the crowing, but I wonder if my hens would be happier without one. Mainly the havoc he causes by his unwanted mating attempts makes me wonder. And the feather damage. I just had to rescue my poor Brahma yesterday who had developed a sore on her back that everyone was pecking at. She has taken to sitting under the coop ramp to get away from the roo (she is 5 and slow from ascites).
What do you think? Thanks!
 
If he's causing more pain than pleasure, it's time for him to go. Our flocks are not supposed to be an aggravation.
See, that’s what I am not sure about. I have always had a rooster. I heard that they calm a flock of hens, though my flock is not very calm at all - maybe it would be complete mayhem without him there?
 
See, that’s what I am not sure about. I have always had a rooster. I heard that they calm a flock of hens, though my flock is not very calm at all - maybe it would be complete mayhem without him there?

You may have just had bad luck with getting roosters who aren't very good at roostering.

Both gentlemen and jerks occur in all species. :)
 
If your hens are unhappy because of the rooster, you should really do something.
But I think that you should just find a good place for him if you do decide that he's got to go- like a rooster sanctuary.
Also, you could try again with roosters to see if a different one would help the flock. I have one crazy Silkie rooster and one agressive Rhode Island Red- who I think has been trying to damage the feathers on one of his hens- but I also once got lucky with a calm, sweet rooster who sacrificed himself when a coyote attacked the chickens. He actually manged to save the hens. There's always the chance you can get very, very lucky with a rooster.
 
Try it without one..see what you think.
Thanks aart. I was hoping to hear from someone with experience with and without rooster about their take on it. Of course I realize flocks differ. I have actually been without a rooster for a few weeks once, while my present roo was just a wee chick. I can’t remember much about that period though.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom