Trying to figure out these chicks!

[Ol Grey Mare]

The bird in question that has been possibly IDd as welsummer or brown leghorn could also very well be a Whiting true green. Out of the 3 that I got this year I had one that looked fairly similar to that. The other 2 Whiting true greens that I received looked just like regular red sex links (the red stars you ordered)as they feathered in and matured.
Have you identified which was your free exotic?

 

[Ol Grey Mare]

There should have been a packing slip....MM uses a sticker on the I side of the lid.....it would have reflected what was actually packed on hatch day and allow for determining if subs were made

 

[Broody Bist]

The yellow and black?

Yep

 

[Lisac45]

There was, I pitched it.

 

[Lisac45]

what makes you say that?

 

[Lisac45]

The bird in question that has been possibly IDd as welsummer or brown leghorn could also very well be a Whiting true green. Out of the 3 that I got this year I had one that looked fairly similar to that. The other 2 Whiting true greens that I received looked just like regular red sex links (the red stars you ordered)as they feathered in and matured.
Have you identified which was your free exotic?

I believe it’s the one in the third pic

 

[Lisac45]

Can't quite see everyone's legs, so consider these guesses for now, first perhaps a splash andalusian, second a welsummer, third a salmon faverolle rooster? Does it have feathered legs?

Well, I got a better look at #3 and he is getting feathers on his legs!