I just started reading through this thread, but had to stop when I read what you said about keeping turkeys in the harsh northern weather. I have had turkeys since last year. Last winter I gave the dummies a coop to go into and they preferred to be out no matter what the weather, and my ducks are the same way. I have a trio of Beltsvilles right now and they roost outside on top of the runs and are out all of the time. I hardly ever find them inside the coop. So, I don't think our winters are too harsh that turkeys will struggle unless they are whimpy birds to begin with.Up until this year I always had bronze - I didn't think the whites were very attractive to live with. I always started out with 15 birds, but lost a third to half of my flock to raccoons. This year, I raised a few whites and three Bourbons for a total of 15, and lost none of them: I was turkey rich.
The Bourbons were my favorite to have around. They jumped, flew and got into more mischief than all the others - I liked having them around. I had to tell guests to park down the driveway a bit because the goofy Bourbons might jump on their car or truck. The only issue I had with the Bourbons is that they don't get very large in the short time I keep them - one hen was only six pounds dressed. I was tempted to keep the bourbons over winter, but I don't have adequate housing for them for our harsh winters.
Next year I might go heavier on the whites, but fewer in total. I gave away 8 turkeys this year, so those people will likely want one next year. The problem is I have a bit over $800.00 invested in them when all is said and done, so I may have to say no to a few people if I raise fewer. Fortunately I have six months or so to decide.
I like having a variety of critters running about the yard. The variety makes summer much more enjoyable for me.
Just sayin'.