two hens, one nest, hatching chicks

Oh my, that is a tough one. I have always put a brooding hen in her own area away from any of my other chickens. Because your other hen was adding eggs to eggs that had been incubating for a longer period, you are not going to get a hatching all at once. I have had silkie mamas, who are the most gentle chickens I have run across, fight like game cocks after they have babies. If they are getting along, leave them together until you don't have any more eggs piping and then move one hen away with the babies leaving the other hen to finish out the other eggs. If all eggs hatch and the mammas are getting along, leave them together and see what happens. You will probably need to put babies and mother(s) in their own area eventually. I don't think it is a good idea and have never had good luck leaving with other grown chickens. I am sure there are other opinions and ideas out there. I hope this helps and maybe someone else will have some other advice or experiences. Good Luck - keep us updated.

 

My mom had this happen and when the chicks started to hatch, one hen attacked them while the other tried to mother them. She ended up separating them out, giving some eggs to one hen and the hatched chicks to the other hen.

The eggs that she gave to the first hen never did hatch, so my mom gave her 5 one day old chicks and took the eggs (she did this at night, so the hen would think they hatched under her.)

 

I had this happen, also - with large fowl breeds.

The only real problem was that they tended to both try to cover the eggs, and being heavy, they broke one or two- killed the chick inside. Once the chicks were born, they both took care of them, the one mama hen better than the other, but the chicks had more than enough mothering.

Next time I plan to put the one hen and her eggs into the brooder cage, so I don't lose so many to shifting chicken butts and feet.

Peace -
Meriah

 

Quote:That's really interesting. A great read! Thanks

 

I have 2 silkie hens that do this EVERY time they go broody. They both raise the babies and everything works out fine. They probably do it better than one mom. They both share the duties and stay all together until the babies are all grown... then they do it again. Don't worry, and like said before, if it's not broke don't fix it, just ENJOY!!

 

This is happening to me right now....6 hens taking care of 3 sets of chics....sharing them.....they were broody together for weeks until babies hatched....and still share small space (2 hens together with chics at nighttime...they are foraging at 4 days old now in the pasture...rooster is protective of them and all the hens eat side by side with them.. in this case it seems to be working well but I have not heard of this before...