Twoo EE's one a cockeral but the other?

[LindsaySinai]

I got 2 EE chicks at the same time and my mom kept swearing the one was going to be a boy because its comb was much bigger and redder....they both ended up being girls. Theyre 9 months now and one has a huge comb and the other is still pretty small. So...the people who are saying they both might be girls definitely could be right.

 

[Lothiriel]

I think both of them are pullets. I have yet to see an EE cockerel with that coloring.

 

[mama24]

THey both look like girls to me. I've never seen a boy that color.

 

[MassivelyScrambled]

The one in question is a pullet. The one you think is a boy could be a pullet as well.

 

[pbjmaker]

I will keep them both then for now. I have a third little EE that is about 4 weeks old too that came from a sexed bunch. If the one ends up a roo then I can take him to the final auction on Oct. 20th or something like that. I just want a green egg layer or two again. My favorite, Bubby died last summer and I had been trying to hatch out an ameraucana since then and kept hatching roos. The one pullet I did get was mean so I had to rehome her, I don't do mean from roos, let alone hens.

 

[SilkieBantams]

I'd say that they're a Cockeral and a Hen

 

[bloom_ss]

Looks like two girls to me.

 

[somadlyinlove]

I'd say both girls kinda look like mine