I actually have WH from both Holderreads and Metzers. They are all beautiful. However, if you ever wanted to get in to showing your birds then you might run into a problem with Metzers. I only have one duck with correct confirmation that could be shown from that flock. Our drake from Metzer Farms doesn't even compare to our Holderread drake. You could see the difference in quality with them when they were just ducklings. My avatar is my Holderread drake. I feel that my Holderread flock is gorgeous all the way around. Now, my favorite WH duck is from Metzer Farms. She loves to greet us every time we enter the coop. She is talkative, sweet, and calm. Her personality out ranks any of the others.
To me it seemed like our Holderread ducklings were more vibrant when they arrived. I put them in the brooder box, and didn't have to worry about them too much. They came a month later than the Metzer Farms ducks, and there were eleven ducks in the box. I only had a few in with the Metzer ducklings. So, all those factors could have played a part in their well being upon arrival. Just don't order any fowl from Metzers during any holiday. Though their website says that they don't ship during the holidays they do. My first order of ducklings died over the Presidents Day holiday. They replaced them but it was a horrible experience!
Both places have pros and cons, and you have a tough choice to make.
To me it seemed like our Holderread ducklings were more vibrant when they arrived. I put them in the brooder box, and didn't have to worry about them too much. They came a month later than the Metzer Farms ducks, and there were eleven ducks in the box. I only had a few in with the Metzer ducklings. So, all those factors could have played a part in their well being upon arrival. Just don't order any fowl from Metzers during any holiday. Though their website says that they don't ship during the holidays they do. My first order of ducklings died over the Presidents Day holiday. They replaced them but it was a horrible experience!
Both places have pros and cons, and you have a tough choice to make.