@GracieJ Hi- It looks like it's been more that a year since any of the members from this thread logged in (and 6 years since the OP was on the site- wowzers!), so I am guessing that the duck in question's coloring will remain a mystery...
(BTW- If you are ever wondering if peps from an old thread are still active members, you can click on their user name. The box that pops up shows the last date they visited BYC at the bottom. )