The Black variety of Plymouth Rock is a variety that has not yet made it to the American Standard of Perfection.
From what I herd from some of the Plymouth Rock breeders I talked to is that the should
(or will have to) have Yellow shacks
(legs) and feet just like the Barred variety of Plymouth Rock.
There is a standard or at least a working standard for the Black Plymouth Rock in the UK and Australian and the last link I posted has a picture of a Black Plymouth Rock as of UK standard.
Now there is a Production breed known as a Black Rock here in the U.S. and in the U.K. that is known as a Black Rock and it has the darker shanks but i
s a cross between a Barred Rock and a Rhode Island Red
(much like a Black Sex-link)....
The Biggest thing that make a Black Plymouth Rock a Black Plymouth Rock and not any other Black breed is the
breeding and the
body type.
All "Standard bred"
(as in bred to the American Standard of Perfection) chickens have a distinct body type that they are bred too.
The Australian Standard 1998
Male & female plumage:Web,fluff & shafts of feathers in all sections,Black.Surface lustrous greenish black. Undercolour black. Beak bright yellow,shanks & toes yellow.
Serious defects Shanks other than yellow,except mature birds which may shade to a light straw
More information on the Black Plymouth Rock UK
http://www.plymouth-rock-poultry.co.uk/blackplymouthrocks.htm
Chris