What went wrong? Maybe I'm just unlucky...

kymmandco

In the Brooder
Jun 19, 2015
19
11
26
Short story long, lol!
Actually I'll try to keep it short, but you can read the LONG story here in my original posts...
https://www.backyardchickens.com/forums/posts/by_user/id/361647

So here's the update...
Out of 40 collected eggs only 6 were fertile and out of them only 2 hatched.
All others died in late development but I don't know why. All were active before going into lock down (I water candled them all on day 16-18 and saw lots of bobbing).

I increased the humidity from 45% to 65% and left closed until I got worried on day 21 for the first egg passed.
BTW after emptying the incubator of all other eggs leaving just the 6 fertile eggs in there we had a gap of 5 days between hatchings.
The first was to be hand reared by my daughter and the other 4 we hoped we could slip under Sophia who has been brooding on ping-pong balls for 2 weeks.
A long shot I know, but the plan was to put the first 2 under her as day olds along with the other 2 eggs to hatch under her, but there's no need to worry about that now as we only ended up with the last 2 hatching.

The first pipped at 3pm, did nothing for about 9-10 hours and then must have gone into fast forward hatching and full of life at 2:25am Friday morning. We left him/her until morning before transferring to the brooder around 8am. That was when I noticed the other one had pipped.
The second was a worry from start to finish. He pipped in the center of the egg and started zipping up towards the tip of the egg. After several hours hitting the same spot and getting nowhere I decided to help. There was no way he could have got out himself and was completely exhausted just lying in his egg for several hours after hatching. He had been shrink wrapped, which may have been due to my opening the incubator to get the first out, maybe also getting disorientated as the first continually knocked into the other eggs rolling them all over the place.

It took many hours for the second chick to start to walk, and had turned up toes and seemed to be fitting and sleeping alot. 2 days later though and he's fine, toes straight, steady on his feet, no more twitching (I think maybe shock was to blame, as his hatch was very quick and traumatising for such a little one) and much more active, although still a little less active than the first.

Saturday night we tried to put both chicks under Sophia, she rejected them.
The first was almost 2 days old and the second 13 hours younger. The first was placed under first, and all seemed to be going well, we watched for about 40mins and thought we'd introduce the second, he ran out in front of her and she attacked it. We saved it and after a few minutes tried again making sure he went under her after removing 4 ping-pong balls to make more room.
We again watched for over an hour and thought maybe she was getting used to the new noises from under her but then she started pecking through her wings at every peep until the little one popped his head out and then she attacked it savagely taking both my daughter and I to save it.
We left the first under and brought the nest box into the living room so we could watch all night, early next morning when the chick popped out again, Sophia grabbed, bit and pecked the chick so we had to remove it too.

Now we have 2 little chicks to hand rear.
Anyone have any advise as to how we do this?
I've only had chickens for about 10 weeks and although I've read just about every book, BYC post and scanned Google for answers to my questions am still very unprepared for any of this.
A total nightmare from start to end, but now I'm a converted chicken lover and just want to find a happy ending.

One more thing...
The friend who dumped her chicks and then hens on me wants to take the chicks when they are 6 weeks old.
She wanted and I agreed she could have 1 chick from each of her 4 hens, (the ones we had incubated that were to be raised by Sophia), but only 2 hatched and Sophia rejected them.
Here's my problem, I and my children have now become very attached to these little ones, they are all we have left of our small flock and now have to hand rear them. Bottom line is, we don't want to give them away, especially as we now have to raise them ourselves.

Should I just cut my losses and give them away keeping my promise, or keep and raise them?
I've spent an awful lot of money, put in time and effort which was hard on top of everything else I have to get done, leaving little or no time for myself and my family.
My coop is now much too big (houses 20-24 hens with 8 nest boxes) and the new enclosure is 3mx6m (10fx20 feet) plus the gravelled area under my 12foot trampoline). A hell of a lot of space for 2 chicks.
I never planned on keeping the 4 (now 3) hens.
They are over 2 years old, don't really lay many eggs and I've learned that Bantams always go broody and wasn't planning on breeding much. This was a fluke and very educational and interesting experience that ended in too much heartache for me to bear.

YES, I do plan on keeping more chickens in the future, starting Spring next year I plan to buy some chicks and just enjoy watching them grow.
I forgot to mention that one hen died, and the other 2 have fertile eggs under them but one has gone over with her 8 and the other is due on Saturday with 4, but due to bad weather, constant moving to separate them and keep them safe from any returning predators I fear none will hatch. Day 23 for Venus and 16 for Isabella. Please pray some of these babies make it.
If you read my other posts from the link above you'll understand me and my story better.

Up to now though, we only have the 2 chicks, and breaking 3 hens from their broody should their eggs not hatch to worry about.
Need advise on breaking broodies without hatching eggs now too.

Summary/questions:
How best to hand rear chicks?
Should I give them away and break my families hearts again?
How do I break a broody hen? Don't suggest hatching eggs as they have sat long enough, the weather is getting colder and colder and I really can't go through all that stress again right now.
Maybe I could just keep tipping them out until they go back to their roost. Would be nice to have a few extra hens in the coop over Winter so I don't have to change coops again and everyone can keep warm together, not that any of the hens or pullets like each other which is why I separated them in the first place.
Venus and Sophia are in my dogs kennels and Isabella is in a nest box in the big coop she's sharing with the surviving pullet, but they don't get along so I may need to rethink that when Isabella breaks her broody (actually all 4 chickens are in individual pet carriers inside these housings including Charlie to help keep her warm at night (poor thing is all alone in this world).

I look forward to any replies.
Thanks in advance.
Kymm.
 
Short story long, lol!
Actually I'll try to keep it short, but you can read the LONG story here in my original posts...
https://www.backyardchickens.com/forums/posts/by_user/id/361647

So here's the update...
Out of 40 collected eggs only 6 were fertile and out of them only 2 hatched.
All others died in late development but I don't know why. All were active before going into lock down (I water candled them all on day 16-18 and saw lots of bobbing).

I increased the humidity from 45% to 65% and left closed until I got worried on day 21 for the first egg passed.
BTW after emptying the incubator of all other eggs leaving just the 6 fertile eggs in there we had a gap of 5 days between hatchings.
The first was to be hand reared by my daughter and the other 4 we hoped we could slip under Sophia who has been brooding on ping-pong balls for 2 weeks.
A long shot I know, but the plan was to put the first 2 under her as day olds along with the other 2 eggs to hatch under her, but there's no need to worry about that now as we only ended up with the last 2 hatching.

The first pipped at 3pm, did nothing for about 9-10 hours and then must have gone into fast forward hatching and full of life at 2:25am Friday morning. We left him/her until morning before transferring to the brooder around 8am. That was when I noticed the other one had pipped.
The second was a worry from start to finish. He pipped in the center of the egg and started zipping up towards the tip of the egg. After several hours hitting the same spot and getting nowhere I decided to help. There was no way he could have got out himself and was completely exhausted just lying in his egg for several hours after hatching. He had been shrink wrapped, which may have been due to my opening the incubator to get the first out, maybe also getting disorientated as the first continually knocked into the other eggs rolling them all over the place.

It took many hours for the second chick to start to walk, and had turned up toes and seemed to be fitting and sleeping alot. 2 days later though and he's fine, toes straight, steady on his feet, no more twitching (I think maybe shock was to blame, as his hatch was very quick and traumatising for such a little one) and much more active, although still a little less active than the first.

Saturday night we tried to put both chicks under Sophia, she rejected them.
The first was almost 2 days old and the second 13 hours younger. The first was placed under first, and all seemed to be going well, we watched for about 40mins and thought we'd introduce the second, he ran out in front of her and she attacked it. We saved it and after a few minutes tried again making sure he went under her after removing 4 ping-pong balls to make more room.
We again watched for over an hour and thought maybe she was getting used to the new noises from under her but then she started pecking through her wings at every peep until the little one popped his head out and then she attacked it savagely taking both my daughter and I to save it.
We left the first under and brought the nest box into the living room so we could watch all night, early next morning when the chick popped out again, Sophia grabbed, bit and pecked the chick so we had to remove it too.

Now we have 2 little chicks to hand rear.
Anyone have any advise as to how we do this?
I've only had chickens for about 10 weeks and although I've read just about every book, BYC post and scanned Google for answers to my questions am still very unprepared for any of this.
A total nightmare from start to end, but now I'm a converted chicken lover and just want to find a happy ending.

One more thing...
The friend who dumped her chicks and then hens on me wants to take the chicks when they are 6 weeks old.
She wanted and I agreed she could have 1 chick from each of her 4 hens, (the ones we had incubated that were to be raised by Sophia), but only 2 hatched and Sophia rejected them.
Here's my problem, I and my children have now become very attached to these little ones, they are all we have left of our small flock and now have to hand rear them. Bottom line is, we don't want to give them away, especially as we now have to raise them ourselves.

Should I just cut my losses and give them away keeping my promise, or keep and raise them?
I've spent an awful lot of money, put in time and effort which was hard on top of everything else I have to get done, leaving little or no time for myself and my family.
My coop is now much too big (houses 20-24 hens with 8 nest boxes) and the new enclosure is 3mx6m (10fx20 feet) plus the gravelled area under my 12foot trampoline). A hell of a lot of space for 2 chicks.
I never planned on keeping the 4 (now 3) hens.
They are over 2 years old, don't really lay many eggs and I've learned that Bantams always go broody and wasn't planning on breeding much. This was a fluke and very educational and interesting experience that ended in too much heartache for me to bear.

YES, I do plan on keeping more chickens in the future, starting Spring next year I plan to buy some chicks and just enjoy watching them grow.
I forgot to mention that one hen died, and the other 2 have fertile eggs under them but one has gone over with her 8 and the other is due on Saturday with 4, but due to bad weather, constant moving to separate them and keep them safe from any returning predators I fear none will hatch. Day 23 for Venus and 16 for Isabella. Please pray some of these babies make it.
If you read my other posts from the link above you'll understand me and my story better.

Up to now though, we only have the 2 chicks, and breaking 3 hens from their broody should their eggs not hatch to worry about.
Need advise on breaking broodies without hatching eggs now too.

Summary/questions:
How best to hand rear chicks?
Should I give them away and break my families hearts again?
How do I break a broody hen? Don't suggest hatching eggs as they have sat long enough, the weather is getting colder and colder and I really can't go through all that stress again right now.
Maybe I could just keep tipping them out until they go back to their roost. Would be nice to have a few extra hens in the coop over Winter so I don't have to change coops again and everyone can keep warm together, not that any of the hens or pullets like each other which is why I separated them in the first place.
Venus and Sophia are in my dogs kennels and Isabella is in a nest box in the big coop she's sharing with the surviving pullet, but they don't get along so I may need to rethink that when Isabella breaks her broody (actually all 4 chickens are in individual pet carriers inside these housings including Charlie to help keep her warm at night (poor thing is all alone in this world).

I look forward to any replies.
Thanks in advance.
Kymm.
Unless you plan on giving up both chicks I wouldn't give up just one. An only chick can be a very lonely (and very loud) chick. Chickens are flock animals and need to be raised (ideally) with a friend or two at least. I had to raise an only and let me tell you, if he wasn't with us he wasn't happy. He became really spoiled really fast.

Chicks need a brooder and a source of heat that will heat one end of the brooder (95F the first week decreasing increments of 5 degrees every following week until they are at room temp or fully feathered in), chick starter and water provided of course. I usually add a small "roost" to my brooder before the end of the first week.

As for breaking broodies...I never have had to yet..knock on wood... but there are a few threads on here dealing with the subject.
 
Thank you for replying. AmyLynn.
We're keeping both chicks and yes I already have a brooder set up with everything they need.
I don't do things by halves, lol.
First I bought a small 7 egg incubator to check fertility, then I got the largest one I could find (non-commercially) that holds 48 eggs, then because I was adding eggs constantly and got worried near the due dates I bought a second to use for lock down, unfortunately due to the egg quality/fertility issues I never got chance to use that one, but come Spring time when I plan to start again it will come in handy.

The chicks are in a clear plastic 45 litre storage box with water dropper that I used cooled boiled water to fill, early feeder (ground cockerel which at first freaked me out, but good to know so many poor roos can still play a part in the early growth of chicks, lol) and chick crumbs. I also treat with crushed suet pellets and mealworm, just like all the chickens they love it, but I don't want to spoil them too much.
They have a large brooder that actually fits up to 20 chicks at one end underlined with just kitchen roll, and food water are quite close to, and coarse sand, edible diatomaceous earth and wood chip to scratch around in. I also put in the holder for the water bottle which resembles un-parallel bars for chicks, lol. They seem to like jumping up and over it, but have not yet learnt to roost. I'm going to make them a little swing and maybe slide to put in there, but they are still too tiny.
I did take them out into the garden yesterday too. They soon started pecking the long grass an scratching. They seem to think my fingers are mum, so when I peck and scratch things they join in. I t still scares me when they peck my hand though. I really hope I can get over that, but I've always feared small animals and insects. The bigger the bug, the less scared I am. I know when they are big chickens I will be okay though, but would love to be able to hold them in my hands right now without the fear I might drop or squash them if they move.

I also read your blog, and am playing your recommended Day Old Chick video over and over in the garden in the hope it will encourage the eggs under the 2 broodies to hatch.
As yet none of the eggs under Venus have hatched and they were due Saturday/Sunday so 2 days over and being Bantams they are more likely to come early than late. I'm just hoping the cold nights have just slowed things down a little and she hatches a couple. She has 10 eggs under her, but only 8 were developed when I candled on day 15/16.
Also our last hope is Isabella who's due on Saturday with 4 out of 6 eggs seemingly doing well. Fingers crossed.

Advise me if you can here...
If Isabella hatches 4 chicks, could I put 2 under Venus if she has none hatch.
I know she wont leave her nest until she has babies and can't let her sit much longer for nothing.
Will Isabella notice they have gone? Will she except them back if rejected? Will she be more likely to reject her other chicks? So many questions, so many different answers on here, so would like to know YOUR thoughts/experiences, please.

Sophia, I'm attempting to break, as I don't think such an aggressive hen can be a good mum.
Maybe if she sits on her own eggs next year, she'll be calmer, I read that chickens are prejudiced and wont except certain chicks based on appearance, colour and imperfections.
I do know that our Frizzle was rejected and bullied by all the other chicks and hens. Also both my border collies singled her out for being different so although it sounds like bull c**p, I think it might be true.

Apparently before Sophia came here she was lovely, but that all changed when she was introduced to my young chicks and became an awful bully although from what I know of her, she's never liked any chicken except Isabella and pecked at the other 2 chickens all the time, so I think because I don't want to keep her, my friend tells me too many lies.
She is however very pretty and good with people, just chickens she doesn't like, lol. She should be rehomed with Isabella and a couple of kids to spoil them (I wanted to give them to school, but they don't want them now just like their previous owners, poor unloved creatures). I love Isabella, but would never separate Sophia from her, that would be so cruel on both of them, but I can't keep them separate from my other chickens either.
I only have Charlie left from my original 9, due to fox/cat attack and plan to keep Venus and any chicks, so really don't want Isabella (Miss Bossy) and Sophia (Miss Nasty) in with them. They separated themselves from all other chickens before going broody and simply don't tolerate any other chickens anywhere near them ever. They need to be on their own together.

WOW, I seem to be going on a little here so will leave it there.
Thanks again for your reply and hope to here back from you again.
Kymm.
 
Honestly, even though I have 4 silkies in my flock (silkies are known for becomming broody) I have never had a hen yet go broody. (I'm not complaining either as I'd rather not have any at this point...lol) So I have absolutely no experience with broody hens or chicks hatched by broody. Sorry. I hope you have a much better hatch next time and thanks for visiting the blog.
 
I agree with Amy on the all or nothing for the chicks, but it sounds like that's your thinking, too. I can, however, help with breaking a broody. The goal is to get them off the nest and cool them off. Their body temperature rises when they are broody, and that's how you break them. I use a "broody cage". I have a bird cage with a wire bottom floor. I put them in the cage, with no bedding, then elevate the cage off the ground by setting it on concrete blocks. The goal is to make them a little uncomfortable, and get air flowing under them to cool them down. The first day you give them only water. The second day you can feed them as well. I've never had a hen take longer than three days breaking this way. I keep them in my shop, where it's not too hot or cold, and keep the light low.
 
I agree with Amy on the all or nothing for the chicks, but it sounds like that's your thinking, too. I can, however, help with breaking a broody. The goal is to get them off the nest and cool them off. Their body temperature rises when they are broody, and that's how you break them. I use a "broody cage". I have a bird cage with a wire bottom floor. I put them in the cage, with no bedding, then elevate the cage off the ground by setting it on concrete blocks. The goal is to make them a little uncomfortable, and get air flowing under them to cool them down. The first day you give them only water. The second day you can feed them as well. I've never had a hen take longer than three days breaking this way. I keep them in my shop, where it's not too hot or cold, and keep the light low.
th.gif
(Agreeing with me.lol) Seriously though... that is very interesting. Good to know.

If anyone knows about broody, he should. You should see all the cotton balls his silkies produce.
gig.gif
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom