Which boy to keep?

HorseGirlAbby

🎒➡️🚗➕🔥🌉
May 14, 2021
11,772
79,420
1,186
Eastern WA
I’ve been mulling this over in my head ever since I knew I got a cockerel in my “guaranteed pullets” batch this spring. I’m looking for opinions and thoughts from other more experienced chicken keepers.

I have a five year old Ameraucana rooster, Mr. Beard. I’ll add a photo of him for fun :D
IMG_7630.jpeg

He is a super sweet rooster, never attacked a person, pretty nice to his hens, and leaves the pullets alone like a good boy. However, he is getting pretty old. I’ve noticed him failing to mate with the hens just because he loses his balance, but he’s still able to make it sometimes.

Then we have Soup, a light Brahma, named that because I assumed that would be his destiny. Of course a picture of this handsome boy is also needed.
IMG_8654.jpeg

He is 18 weeks old now, and just recently learned to crow. He’s never attacked anybody, and when he’s not chasing pullets around (🙄) he’s very sweet.

I put Soup in with the hens a couple weeks ago, as I was integrating the pullets and thought I would give him a chance with the hens. He was absolutely terrified of them. Of course my tiniest hen, who’s less than half his size, was the meanest to him. He was in there for about a week, until I got tired of him chasing the pullets around way too much. Then I switched the roosters out, and there was a definite shift in the flock dynamic. The hens were so much happier to have their old guy back, he was happy, and the pullets were happy they weren’t being chased all the time.

I know Soup is still young, and I’m willing to give him a couple more months to mature. He’s currently in with my two special needs hens, who are having the time of their lives making him behave in there 😂

The main thing I’m worried about is his size. He’s much bigger than the hens already, and he’s just a baby. One of my pullets is a Leghorn, and she’s so tiny she looks like a bantam. Has anyone had problems with a rooster this much bigger than the hens?

It just doesn’t make sense to get rid of a young, strong rooster to keep the old one. Whoever we don’t keep is going to become soup though, and Soup the cockerel would be much better eating…

Thanks for reading my rambling post, I appreciate it. Any thoughts on this are welcome :)
 
I’ve been mulling this over in my head ever since I knew I got a cockerel in my “guaranteed pullets” batch this spring. I’m looking for opinions and thoughts from other more experienced chicken keepers.

I have a five year old Ameraucana rooster, Mr. Beard. I’ll add a photo of him for fun :D
View attachment 4175247
He is a super sweet rooster, never attacked a person, pretty nice to his hens, and leaves the pullets alone like a good boy. However, he is getting pretty old. I’ve noticed him failing to mate with the hens just because he loses his balance, but he’s still able to make it sometimes.

Then we have Soup, a light Brahma, named that because I assumed that would be his destiny. Of course a picture of this handsome boy is also needed.
View attachment 4175254
He is 18 weeks old now, and just recently learned to crow. He’s never attacked anybody, and when he’s not chasing pullets around (🙄) he’s very sweet.

I put Soup in with the hens a couple weeks ago, as I was integrating the pullets and thought I would give him a chance with the hens. He was absolutely terrified of them. Of course my tiniest hen, who’s less than half his size, was the meanest to him. He was in there for about a week, until I got tired of him chasing the pullets around way too much. Then I switched the roosters out, and there was a definite shift in the flock dynamic. The hens were so much happier to have their old guy back, he was happy, and the pullets were happy they weren’t being chased all the time.

I know Soup is still young, and I’m willing to give him a couple more months to mature. He’s currently in with my two special needs hens, who are having the time of their lives making him behave in there 😂

The main thing I’m worried about is his size. He’s much bigger than the hens already, and he’s just a baby. One of my pullets is a Leghorn, and she’s so tiny she looks like a bantam. Has anyone had problems with a rooster this much bigger than the hens?

It just doesn’t make sense to get rid of a young, strong rooster to keep the old one. Whoever we don’t keep is going to become soup though, and Soup the cockerel would be much better eating…

Thanks for reading my rambling post, I appreciate it. Any thoughts on this are welcome :)
My husband cracked up when I read aloud about Soup, his name due to possible destiny.

I would wait. Reason, if Mr Beard is having trouble with balance, it will probably worsen.

Has Soup been outside with Mr Beard at any time? If not, would it be worth trying? Of course, have a water bottle with a strong stream and or a stick. Our senior chased our young cockerel (4.5 months) but not to attack, just get him away from the hens/pullets. Would Mr. Beard possibly show Soup the ropes? Tidbits, Escort, Alerts, etc. I'm just thinking as I know I will have to do this in a couple of years.

I'm interested in what other knowledgeable members write.
 
My husband cracked up when I read aloud about Soup, his name due to possible destiny.

I would wait. Reason, if Mr Beard is having trouble with balance, it will probably worsen.

Has Soup been outside with Mr Beard at any time? If not, would it be worth trying? Of course, have a water bottle with a strong stream and or a stick. Our senior chased our young cockerel (4.5 months) but not to attack, just get him away from the hens/pullets. Would Mr. Beard possibly show Soup the ropes? Tidbits, Escort, Alerts, etc. I'm just thinking as I know I will have to do this in a couple of years.

I'm interested in what other knowledgeable members write.
Since I have Soup in a chicken tractor, and I let the hens and Mr. Beard out to free range sometimes, they’ve interacted just through the fence. I have a strong feeling it would not end well for poor Soup. I tried having another cockerel in with Mr. Beard once, and the cockerel ended up starving to death while I was gone, which obviously is not ideal. Soup has tidbitted for his pullets, and cares about them. He can sometimes see them in the run, and paces back and forth trying to get to them.
 
I would want a son of the wellbehaved Mr. Beard to be his successor as often characteristis/traits will be inherited.
Unfortunately I’m not able to hatch more eggs right now, as I’m at my limit with chickens. I have hatched from him before, and got some cockerels. One of them was shaping up to be pretty nice, but two of them were showing signs of possible aggression toward humans.
The young Brahma will soon be too big/heavy for most of your hens and you don't know if he will be accepted by your hens or if he will be respectful of humans once the older male is gone.
He’s not currently in with the rooster, so he’s not really being kept in line, and is still sweet. I agree though, he’s getting very big.
 
I vote neither.

Soup for dinner.

Find another Cockerel or even a nice rooster in a size appropriate breed. You'll have your pick this time of year and still have time to quarantine him. See if Mr. Beard can train him up and then coq au vin Mr Beard in the fall.
 
I was also worried about having a rooster that is too big for my hens and I ended up selling my Brahma cockerel. His father was 15 pounds so he would've gotten very large and my littlest EE hen is probably around 4 pounds.
I’m hoping someone who’s actually had a big rooster will chime in, because those are my thoughts exactly…
I vote neither.

Soup for dinner.

Find another Cockerel or even a nice rooster in a size appropriate breed. You'll have your pick this time of year and still have time to quarantine him. See if Mr. Beard can train him up and then coq au vin Mr Beard in the fall.
That is definitely an idea, and there’s no shortage of free roosters in my area.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom