Which Is The Best Pie Of Them All??? -2025 Pie Poll-

[TXchickmum]

-from the list: pecan, but not my fav
-preference: chocolate meringue
-second: buttermilk (not chess)
...and my dear old grandmother made a "meal" pie similar to a buttermilk pie. -made with cornmeal and buttermilk. Unique for sure.

 

[urlocalcrazychickenlady]

My fave is Dutch apple pie!! It’s fr the best! I use tastes better from scratch recipe

 

[azurbanclucker]

I went lemon (because lemon meringue). However, it's criminal that strawberry rhubarb is not on this list.

 

[BoundlessLove]

-from the list: pecan, but not my fav
-preference: chocolate meringue
-second: buttermilk (not chess)
...and my dear old grandmother made a "meal" pie similar to a buttermilk pie. -made with cornmeal and buttermilk. Unique for sure.

My aunt used to make this pie a long time ago.
Yep, you use cornmeal. It was so good. I had forgotten about it until your post. Good memories!

 

[MamaPoult]

BLACKBERRY PIE

Yesss! My brother talked me into helping him make one for Thanksgiving. It turned out good!! I really liked it, it was my first time having it lol

I’d say from your list would choose apple or cherry.
None of those are my favorite/s though.

My favorites in NO certain order:
Sweet Potato pie
Blackberry pie (not just any berries)
Egg Custard pie
Buttermilk pie - this is NOT chess pie folks

Ahhh I forgot so many!!! What in the world it buttermilk pie...? It sounds good. Is sweet potato pie similar to sweet potato casserole?

Chocolate anything beats most anything else.

Gotta agree with you there. Chocolate is superior

From your list, I picked apple but Buttermilk pie is better

Family's all-time favorite - my pecan pie.

Nostalgic favorite - mincemeat pie.

Okay, now I wish I'd of put buttermilk! Pecan pie is amazing, I've never had mincemeat pie though.....

cherry pie ! and mince pie for Christmas.

Yess cherry is awesome!!!! I need to try this mince pie thing

Berry pie!!!!!! And apple. And lemon/lime.

Yes! I've never had a lemon or lime pie but I am determined to

 

[MamaPoult]

-from the list: pecan, but not my fav
-preference: chocolate meringue
-second: buttermilk (not chess)
...and my dear old grandmother made a "meal" pie similar to a buttermilk pie. -made with cornmeal and buttermilk. Unique for sure.

So interesting! Cornmeal and buttermilk actually sounds super good. Yesss pecan is awesome!

My fave is Dutch apple pie!! It’s fr the best! I use tastes better from scratch recipe

Oooooh what makes it different from a normal pie. Is it just the spices or style??? It sounds amazing, good choice!

I went lemon (because lemon meringue). However, it's criminal that strawberry rhubarb is not on this list.

Okay, I NEED to have a lemon meringue soon! They sound heavenly . Noooo I'm sorry. I felt like I was forgetting strawberry but then I was like I've never seen a strawberry pie! That sounds yummy though.

My aunt used to make this pie a long time ago.
Yep, you use cornmeal. It was so good. I had forgotten about it until your post. Good memories!

Yes I'm gonna have to look this up. It sounds amazing!

 

[ShrekDawg]

Yesss! My brother talked me into helping him make one for Thanksgiving. It turned out good!! I really liked it, it was my first time having it lol

Ahhh I forgot so many!!! What in the world it buttermilk pie...? It sounds good. Is sweet potato pie similar to sweet potato casserole?

Gotta agree with you there. Chocolate is superior

Okay, now I wish I'd of put buttermilk! Pecan pie is amazing, I've never had mincemeat pie though.....

Yess cherry is awesome!!!! I need to try this mince pie thing

Yes! I've never had a lemon or lime pie but I am determined to

They’re SO. GOOD.