Which Marans rooster should I keep?

[csherer]

I have 3 Birchan Marans roosters and I can only keep one. Would love some input on which one you would keep and ranking them in order would be great too. The larger ones have oversized combs, but I don't know if I should allow the comb to make my decision.Thanks! By the way the ones I don't keep are for sale
The first choice and only pic
The second choice and includes 3 pics


The 3rd choice and two pics

 

[hnichols]

first

 

[BantyChooks]

personally, I like the first.

 

[csherer]

I forgot to mention they are only 5 months old and are already over 8 lbs. The first one is the smallest at 8 lbs. I lean toward the first also, but the second is definitely the biggest. Is it a disqualification or a fault that his comb touches the nape of the neck?

 

[Maikan]

I breed Marans and I would def choose the 1st Rooster.

 

[BantyChooks]

sorry, I don't know anything about marans........

........I just like the looks of the first one.

 

[csherer]

Thanks everyone for your advise. I kinda thought the first was the one to go with. Just started raising Marans and wanted to be sure.

 

[csherer]

Is it a disqualification if the comb touches the nape of the neck, or is it a fault?