Which rooster should stay?

[AmeraucanaHank]

Keep whichever one you want id personally keep the ee as single combs birds where i am fall off due to the cold

I agree, plus If you ever decide to hatch your own eggs they all might lay a colored eggs!!!

 

[Chicken poppy]

I agree, plus If you ever decide to hatch your own eggs they all might lay a colored eggs!!!

I don’t think they would all lay different colors? If bred to the same hen. Maybe different shades though.

 

[TRALALARA1]

My EE rooster is super protective of his hens. I’ve taken to carrying a shovel around. He hasn’t attacked me but he does show aggression. On the other hand, he is a very attentive fellow to his hens. My barred rock rooster follows me around like a dog and has never showed the slightest aggression BUT he is low man on the totem pole. The EE is top dog for sure.

 

[Ebony Rose]

Mating with an EE rooster is like a box o' chocolates, ya ne'er know whatcha gonna get.

I love my EE and crossbred birds, and the EE hens I've had are happy to brood. When grown, these hens lay medium to large eggs (color depends on their ancestors), and the cockerels mature at about six or seven months, being large enough to process for a dinner table set for four with leftovers.

 

[Chicken poppy]

Mating with an EE rooster was like a box o' chocolates, ya ne'er know whatcha gonna get.

I love my EE and crossbred birds, and the EE hens I've had are happy to brood. When grown, these hens lay medium to large eggs (color depends on their ancestors), and the cockerels mature at about six or seven months, being large enough to process for a dinner table set for four with leftovers.

Mandela effect

 

[mydaisy]

They look like din

My EE rooster is super protective of his hens. I’ve taken to carrying a shovel around. He hasn’t attacked me but he does show aggression. On the other hand, he is a very attentive fellow to his hens. My barred rock rooster follows me around like a dog and has never showed the slightest aggression BUT he is low man on the totem pole. The EE is top dog for sure.

This EE cockerel seems aggressive to the EE pullet and her only. Not often, but he will pounce on her sometimes and nip at her neck. He also seems protective of her, too. I can’t figure him out. But aggression towards the girls are a big deal breaker, but I’m wondering if this is a young cockerel thing.

 

[mydaisy]

Mating with an EE rooster is like a box o' chocolates, ya ne'er know whatcha gonna get.

I love my EE and crossbred birds, and the EE hens I've had are happy to brood. When grown, these hens lay medium to large eggs (color depends on their ancestors), and the cockerels mature at about six or seven months, being large enough to process for a dinner table set for four with leftovers.

I’m new to EEs, I’m excited to see how they are when they’re older.

 

[Chicken poppy]

This EE cockerel seems aggressive to the EE pullet and her only. Not often, but he will pounce on her sometimes and nip at her neck. He also seems protective of her, too. I can’t figure him out. But aggression towards the girls are a big deal breaker, but I’m wondering if this is a young cockerel thing.

Are you sure he isn’t trying to mate her? He could be confused on doing that or something.

 

[janiedoe]

Personally, I would keep both for several weeks. Let them mature a bit, before you make your mind up. Their personalities may change completely. One or both may be aggressive to you or the hens/pullets. They both might be sweethearts.
I'm betting the easter egger is trying to mate with the easter egger pullet. They're not really too suave at that age.

 

[janiedoe]

Dino dogs.

I don't know either. Enlighten us?