Which rooster would you keep?

[LaFleche]

Thanks for the great feed back , I didn't breed them bought them as day olds so not sure about parents.

The darker one seems to have a odd comb however not as smooth as the lighter one.

Yes, that is true. The comb of the lighter one looks better, so it will be 'comb or lacing' unless one of them is healthier or better behaved.