Which rooster

[chipens]

Hello, I have 4 barred rock cockerels, I'm wanting to keep one for breeding.
I've picked 2 out of the 4 but still unsure
One has a comb defect, has the nicest biggest comb but has a cut through the back he's also a bit short and stumpy hes in backgroundof a pic.
Other has funny tail and is quite light.
Two I've pictured are my options
I've also added a photo of the standard.
It's hard to get decent photos
Help
Thanks

 

[LavenderDaFlerf]

2

 

[Amer]

2 appears to be the better as he is larger and more developed overall.
While 1 appears to have a better tail, his breast is too shallow and his head is overrefined.

 

[chipens]

My pick was 2 also, but i thought ones feather colour is better than 2's
I tried again with the pics

 

[ChickenLover515]

Hello, I have 4 barred rock cockerels, I'm wanting to keep one for breeding.
I've picked 2 out of the 4 but still unsure
One has a comb defect, has the nicest biggest comb but has a cut through the back he's also a bit short and stumpy hes in backgroundof a pic.
Other has funny tail and is quite light.
Two I've pictured are my options
I've also added a photo of the standard.
It's hard to get decent photos
Help
Thanks
View attachment 3045905View attachment 3045906View attachment 3045907View attachment 3045908

 

[ChickenLover515]

 

[ChickenLover515]

This is my 2 ft. tall barred rock rooster Soos

 

[ChickenLover515]

The black-bearded hen is a green queen. her name is Queeny

 

[Amer]

The black-bearded hen is a green queen. her name is Queeny

I have a chicken named Queeny too. Nice Corgi!