Which Sumatra roo should I keep?! (pic heavy)

[senrabruk]

like everyone else I ended up with two Roos and only need one

I am going to do some showing and hopefuly raise a some chickies!
they both are sweet to me and the girls. the are still young they are about 15-16weeks old.
these are my first sumatras sooo I don't really know what to look for.
which would you keep????
or should I wait till they are older?
thanks soo much for the help!

Roo#1

he has very yellow feet #2 has more of a pink tint is that ok?

Roo#2

And here they are together

 

[Tanichca]

for the very last pic, the one on the left looks better. but im no expert...

 

[Henferno]

Roo #1 is a winner. Yellow feet are better than pink, dark eyes are better than copper, straight tail carriage is far more desirable in Sumatras, with the chests carried high (#2 looks slouchy)... #2 has better green sheen, but that's about it.
In my experience, though, for some reason the ones that look like Roo #2 often have more spurs... it depends what you're breeding for, but I'd go with #1 for most projects, especially showing.

They're both cute, though.

 

[Muscovies]

Roo 1# I agree with Henferno

 

[senrabruk]

OK thanks!
I guess that #2 is the one to go.

 

[Liamm_1]

I'd wait a while, if you can. My 2 roos were hard to tell apart body-wise at 15-16 weeks. Now at 21 they are very easy to distinguish. but yes, yellow feet is better.