Whick ones should I keep? pic

[ArizonaDesertChicks]

1. black sexlink / black star - definitely a female (males have different coloring)
2, 3, 4, - my guess is females - I don't see any pink in their combs yet
5. definitely a male - red comb & wattles

I have 6 different breeds of chickens and my black stars are the calmest and friendliest yet - they're also supposed to lay LOTS of big brown eggs.

 

[Delta2 23]

I love the first one... it's so cute and it looks like a girl.

 

[PlumTuckered]

I'm no expert but #2 looks like a RIR pullet , #3 looks like a Brown Leghorn pullet and #5 looks like a SLW (ROO)

Michelle

 

[HorseFeathers]

Looks like all pullets but #5. Look at those thick legs and big red wattles and comb. SLW. I presume since you can only have 3 you live in the city and therefore roosters aren't good?

As far as keeping the rest, I would go based on personality. The first two are 1, a black sexlink, and 2, a RIR or possibly a NHR (hatchery quality). 3 & 4 I don't know what they are, but black sexlinks lay lots of eggs, so do RIRs!