Who layed these eggs

[smfarman]

Yesterday I got a brown egg and today I got a brown egg, but today's egg color is darker and it's a bit smaller. I don't know who laid them. I have buff orpington and wyandotte, so can someone tell me who laid which one

 

[ChickNanny13]

My guess is the Wyandotte laid the egg on the left & the Orpington the one on the right.

 

[smfarman]

My guess is the Wyandotte laid the egg on the left & the Orpington the one on the right.

Thank you for help

 

[ChickNanny13]

 

[aart]

My guess is the Wyandotte laid the egg on the left & the Orpington the one on the right.

I would guess the opposite
My Wyandottes laid pinkish eggs.

 

[ChickNanny13]

I would guess the opposite
My Wyandottes laid pinkish eggs.

I stand corrected, my Orps lay pinkish eggs & speckled eggs Colors sometimes varied but I knew who laid by the shape of the eggs. Looking for the pics of my Wyandottes eggs ...

 

[aart]

Ya really gotta 'catch them in the act' to know for sure.
I've never had Orps.

 

[smfarman]

Ya really gotta 'catch them in the act' to know for sure.
I've never had Orps.

Thank you for your help, I am happy that I finally got brown eggs and I'll be watching them during the week to find out who is laying which ones.

 

[CindyinSD]

My Buff Orpingtons lay lighter colored eggs & the Wyandottes’ eggs are darker, but the variations in brown eggs are often unpredictable.

 

[smfarman]

My Buff Orpingtons lay lighter colored eggs & the Wyandottes’ eggs are darker, but the variations in brown eggs are often unpredictable.

Thank you, I wasn't sure because I've only had RIRs and black Australorps about 5 years ago.
Six of eight that are in this group all have very red combs and wattles.