I have a gallon mixed up for our one 12 day old bottle pygmy. Whole milk, buttermilk and evaporated milk(as per recipe found on here/backyardherds). I mixed it up on Monday and its about half gone right now. My question is, how long does it stay(it is in the fridge)? Its looking like its wanting to turn into cheese. Especially when I warm it in the microwave. Does anyone know how long it should stay fresh? Is it time to make a new batch?? If it is going bad, I think I'll just have to mix up half batches! Thanks!