With all due respect, I have read every post in this thread, and I think it is a successful thread. I, for one, have been very interested in the variety of opinions and methods of acquiring and raising chicks.
I also agree with
@Shadrach that in a PERFECT world, breeding chickens more naturally, is better for the chickens. However, obviously, it is not a perfect world, and many of us, myself included, want and need something different from our chickens. In his situation, chickens that brood and raise chicks in a flock, sub flock, tribe, whatever, works in the chicken's favor. For myself, the LAST thing I want is a hen going broody, it would not be a healthy situation for a bird that will never, ever hatch and raise chicks. There is a place for hens that still know how to raise their own, AND a place for hens that wouldn't bother.
You are both entitled to your opinions, and that's all they are, so play nice. please. I for one, don't want this thread to deteriorate into name calling, I'm enjoying it. My guess, based on the number of posts, it that others are too. Ok, done with the lecture.