I just hate to kill her she is one of my favorite sweeties, thankfully right now she is the only one in her small hen house, other than the roo, the others are small yet and are in their own area, I don't think that they did feed her eggs shells simply because 1. she came to me very young, barely just started laying. 2. she came to me laying very very soft eggs, some so soft they barely held together by a membrane.3. they were very unknowledgeable able about chickens and I doubt that they knew that they should even give her shells or calcium especially due to the condition of her eggs when I got her. So I put one of the rock eggs in her nest, but she still seems to be doing it.....you might be right she might have to go. Maybe I will try to make the hot sauce eggs, does anybody think that maybe her house is too small and hot and that could be a reason? We got her coop with her and are in the process of building a new one.....? Ya know now that I am thinking about it maybe I need to rephrase my original question, shes not really eating them she is breaking them, the shell is there, just nothing else. I have heard that people will cut their beaks to keep them from doing this is this a good way to treat this problem? I am really leary about that .