Hi Amy
I'm in Licking County/ Johnstown area (a pretty good drive from you!) I've been to Galloway once or twice. We really think the mysterious dissapearances are this cat (or cats)...if you live in farm country you're bound to have em and, as I said, our farmer neighbor doesn't care much about how many kittens his cats have. We've had chickens for two years, and the first year we had very little problems with predators; what problems we did have were almost all in the barn when they were roosting or on the nest box. We've had one casualty from a hawk, two or three from possums, 4 or 5 from skunks, 3 or 4 from weasels, 1 from a dog (ours, when we first got chickens), and about 12 - 15 from coons, 1 known from the cat, as well as 4 or 5 MIA's. I think the best thing to do is get a good rooster or two; it's interesing watching them trying to watch out for the flock and they usually do a pretty good job outside. And we only had two or three coons that did all that damage, and that was this year; we think we accidentally attracted them to the barn cause we had buried a couple of chickens who died from being ill, too close to the barn, and the critters discovered em and dug them up. We had a fox living by our pond and raising her kits in a den there for many years; but we never saw her near our chickens; she did a good job of keeping the Canada Geese out of our pond, though!