New doesn't mean a thing. Sometimes brand new thermometers can be 10° off or more. Still, them agreeing is a good sign. I'll find a list tomorrow... oh, and if you're sure they're dead; eggtopsy and take pictures, please... sometimes they can be most helpful in diagnosing a failed hatch.
Are they calibrated? That's good, though. Where did you get the eggs? Were the parent birds being fed good quality food?
I can't get a chart of causes of late term deaths right now, unfortunately, but I will tomorrow.
Your humidity looks way higher than 73%. I would be very skeptical of the control's accuracy. Please get another thermometer/hygrometer, calibrate them, and try setting incubator conditions by that. Also, you might well need lower humidity; they won't hatch well or at all if the air cell is too...
What incubator did you use, still air or forced? Do you have a separate thermometer or were you trusting a digital thermometer/thermostat in the incubator?