➡I accidentally bought Balut eggs: 2 live ducks! Now a Chat Thread!

Mine just happen to be a bit more on the fringe than standard, which gives me trouble when I try to research them. Library books on elevators? Few and far between. Internet pages that even mention elevator governors? Less than 80.

Aww that’s unfortunate!!

... but i'm still not reading the elevator book!

:lau

Just think of all the poor people that know me in real life and have to listen to me rant on the inaccuracy of elevator scenes in movies.

I have GOT to hear your thoughts on this!
Please... indulge me! :lau:pop:pop:pop

X2 :lau

Don't worry I probably won't make it through 5 pages before I quit.

I read the intro and couldn’t get past it lol

Oh boy you have no idea what you are getting in to.

Whaaat?! I didn't know that elevator scenes were so inaccurate and I am very into inaccuracies in films and TV, actually! Elevators never even crossed my mind!

Fine. But be warned, you started this. :gig

You never notice when things are changed around in the scene when the camera just moves for a second and comes back and it looks different.
I spot these kind of errors a mile away.

I ALWAYS notice these things!
And I love pointing them out. My family hates it.

:lau omg lol

But also I notice things like that. Or in a different spot than before or whatever. Annoys me too LOL
 
I'm going to turn on Captain America right now...I think I might know what you're talking about. Is it towards the middle? Right after they inject him with super strength?
No, I'm not even sure which movie it's in. He's got a suit on, not the civilian clothes he's wearing when he does his first chase after the serum, and that painted shield. It's that elevator fight with all the armed dudes that get in. He pastes all of them and jumps out the side of the glass elevator car, I think.
 
I don't notice camera errors (except for one crazy one where two characters swapped spots mid scene) because I don't pay enough attention. I'm sure it would bug me if I got more into them.
There are several climbing scenes in movies where the rope systems are SO wrong. They're either pulling on the wrong colored rope, it's anchored into one spot and miraculously changes or rocks suddenly appear that were not there before.
 
I am not familiar with very many movies or TV shows—it's mainly just what the kids watch—but there have been a few falling elevator scenes. The first one was in one of the Captain America movies. Steve (main character) cuts the top cables with his shield thingy in his bid to escape some people that were chasing him. The elevator falls at rapidly increasing speed, before the governor kicks in and activates the brakes. So far, so good. It even had correct rail placement. But then the brakes start sparking and keep dragging down... and down.. and wait, once the brakes are activated by the overspeed being tripped, the car stops in 6.5 inches, according to one source. It doesn't take five seconds, and it sure doesn't stop smoothly enough for Steve to keep his feet! :barnie The next one was from somewhere in season one of the X-Files. Some computer software became self-aware and started killing people, one by taking the elevator up to the 29th floor then dropping the car. The issue here is that governors work on a mechanical system, not electronic, bar the first switch that trips at a slightly lower speed than the flyweights which will overcome the springs with centrifugal force and stop the wheel from rotating with the speeding car. So, how could a purely computational force overcome a safety system powered by physics?? It can't, unless it got a person to do it, and the rest of the episode clearly showed it was working alone. There was even a shot of the intact governor spinning at speeds more than high enough to trip the physical system. So, unless my sources are all wrong, their representation of elevator failures are incorrect. If it was an older elevator with a unidirectional governor... the computer in the second example could have sped up the lift mechanism electronically and smashed it into the roof. That I could buy. But they didn't do that.

Wow I have never thought about that before but I can see why you would be annoyed!! But that said, I don’t think much of anything is accurate in movies, that’s why it’s a movie and I don’t think they aim for accuracy as much as entertainment value so I don’t really get as annoyed at that stuff. It wouldn’t be entertaining if it was accurate. :p but there’s been some stuff in the Marvel TV shows or my crime shows and stuff where I’m like that’s so fake/no way that would actually happen or be possible, etc. but I can’t remember any specifics now lol

I don't notice camera errors (except for one crazy one where two characters swapped spots mid scene) because I don't pay enough attention. I'm sure it would bug me if I got more into them.

Wait... what show? Now I have to see this LOL

I'm going to turn on Captain America right now...I think I might know what you're talking about. Is it towards the middle? Right after they inject him with super strength?

I am trying to watch all the Marvel movies but haven’t gotten that far yet lol watched all the Avengers ones (gave up on in order lol) and I have watched some of the individual character ones over the years but am now trying to watch those in order. I like the ones with all the characters though so I watched those first ha
 
Wow I have never thought about that before but I can see why you would be annoyed!! But that said, I don’t think much of anything is accurate in movies, that’s why it’s a movie and I don’t think they aim for accuracy as much as entertainment value so I don’t really get as annoyed at that stuff. It wouldn’t be entertaining if it was accurate. :p but there’s been some stuff in the Marvel TV shows or my crime shows and stuff where I’m like that’s so fake/no way that would actually happen or be possible, etc. but I can’t remember any specifics now lol



Wait... what show? Now I have to see this LOL



I am trying to watch all the Marvel movies but haven’t gotten that far yet lol watched all the Avengers ones (gave up on in order lol) and I have watched some of the individual character ones over the years but am now trying to watch those in order. I like the ones with all the characters though so I watched those first ha
I will suspend my disbelief over just about anything—but I draw the line at incorrect elevator scenes.
 
I am not familiar with very many movies or TV shows—it's mainly just what the kids watch—but there have been a few falling elevator scenes. The first one was in one of the Captain America movies. Steve (main character) cuts the top cables with his shield thingy in his bid to escape some people that were chasing him. The elevator falls at rapidly increasing speed, before the governor kicks in and activates the brakes. So far, so good. It even had correct rail placement. But then the brakes start sparking and keep dragging down... and down.. and wait, once the brakes are activated by the overspeed being tripped, the car stops in 6.5 inches, according to one source. It doesn't take five seconds, and it sure doesn't stop smoothly enough for Steve to keep his feet! :barnie The next one was from somewhere in season one of the X-Files. Some computer software became self-aware and started killing people, one by taking the elevator up to the 29th floor then dropping the car. The issue here is that governors work on a mechanical system, not electronic, bar the first switch that trips at a slightly lower speed than the flyweights which will overcome the springs with centrifugal force and stop the wheel from rotating with the speeding car. So, how could a purely computational force overcome a safety system powered by physics?? It can't, unless it got a person to do it, and the rest of the episode clearly showed it was working alone. There was even a shot of the intact governor spinning at speeds more than high enough to trip the physical system. So, unless my sources are all wrong, their representation of elevator failures are incorrect. If it was an older elevator with a unidirectional governor... the computer in the second example could have sped up the lift mechanism electronically and smashed it into the roof. That I could buy. But they didn't do that.
Ok... you're right. I'm pretty confident that the elevator stop was WAY too smooth to be real!
 
No, I'm not even sure which movie it's in. He's got a suit on, not the civilian clothes he's wearing when he does his first chase after the serum, and that painted shield. It's that elevator fight with all the armed dudes that get in. He pastes all of them and jumps out the side of the glass elevator car, I think.


I love this movie and scene and thought it was so badass but never noticed the error LOL
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom