I would make sure the gages are all correct and recommend trying a low humidity incubation, provided you aren't in a high altitude and monitor the air cells to know when/how to adjust. The styro bators especially seem to do better with a lower humidity when possible. Often humidity in the 50's will cause chicks drowning because it prevents the eggs from loosing the moisture that they need to. Some people can successfully hatch at that level, but for the majority, lower is proving to be better. Why 17? Because most people start lockdown at day 18 and raise the humidity.
I really stress checking the thermometers because I know what happens when you trust one that hasn't been checked. Bought a brand new one my first hatch never checked it, found out at the end (after a VERY bad hatch) that it was 6 degrees off, so stressing checking your instruments is par for course. And one mantra you will hear again and again on here from many people. That and NEVER trust the incubator's gages, especially in the LGs and FIs.
Now, you are maintaining your temps about 101-102F taken near the tops f the eggs, right? Now the chicks that are hatching, are they hatching "on time"?
Here's a humidity link if you are interested:
http://letsraisechickens.weebly.com...anuals-understanding-and-controlling-humidity