Is it O.K. to shoot the neighbors' dog if it comes over to kill my girls? He won't return my phone calls. I went over to have a chat with him after I found my Black Star dead on the front porch with dog tracks leading back to his house. His wife, obviously on some major medication, answered the door and couldn't have cared less. Two weeks later I discovered what was left of my Rhode Island Red in his yard. Today I found this dog trying to dig a hole under the barn door, but by the time I got the gun it was gone.