In Joy's recipe, she says to let it cool to 110. I'm kinda thinking that's what I did wrong. I did see online in lots of videos, that some blend at 135-145 degrees. I wonder if it depends on the oils you're using. I knew better, knew I should follow the recipe, that Joy's been doing this for years. But I got anxious. Next time I'll do the ice water bath.
And I didn't add the oatmeal and EO right away, not until it traced, so that rules that out.
And, boy, does it smell awesome!! I just want to dive in. lol Good luck on your soap, Kassandra!