No one is saying it is superior to goats milk, but given a choice between milk replacer and whole cows milk, cows is the way to go. If I have to feed a few only bottle feeding is it more economical to use replacer if you can find a good one. I have used a no soy one that I have no problems with. But if I am just suplimenting or just one kid it is easier and they seem to do better on cows milk (then replacer)