HUH
all that is confusing me.
Sorry. Which part?
Ameraucana is a breed with standards-- standards are opinions which are agreed upon and set down as judging rules.
Genetics determines a breed, but genes are tricky tricky tricky.
If we are going to call a breed of chicken a name that means 'not this breed' then we need to be clear what makes the breed. I get that. BUT when talking about genetic preferences and projects where people breed in other breeds of chickens for their body type or colors, they are working on genetics and with opinions again. They 'like' this color or shape. It isn't about the breed standard or its heritage (just to use another confusing word.) BYC needs a lexicon of terms simplified and agreed to-- an SOP for terms

My issue with folks claiming every AM cull or Am whose appearance doesn't meet SOPs an EE is that it creates confusion about breeds instead of being clear about non-standard/non-breed types. EE never explains itself

The EE term isn't working well. I was trying to say that if you are breeding Ams and you breed an Am to an Am (AmxAm, irregardless of color ) then it is an Ameraucana. If it doesn't meet SOP then it is just that; Non Standard of Perfection Ameraucana (NS Am in my mind but I am not trying to create more anacronyms, just keeping the typing down a little.) If it is a cross breed, an Ameraucana with something else, then its an EE. The egg color trait is dominant so any cross will have the colored egg-- hence, EE being not Am.
When projects are started, people use other breeds to introduce typing-- color type, body type etc. and then breed carefully to get a bird whic meets the standards set out for as many types as can meet the SOP but with that new trait (color usually). Those initial generations of cross breeds are not Ams but EEs (EE= not Am). Careful breeding can bring the offspring to a point where they 'breed true' and then wait around to get approval (recognition) from APA as a SOP option. Example: Silver laced Brahmas. Blue Laced Ams. When the offspring meet all the standards *but with that new color* every generation that is breeding true. They are breeding out the old traits of the other bird bred to create new color and continuing to breed ones carrying the new color hoping that a wildcard gene doesn't pop up, hence the wait to get recognition (ie if the new color Ams produce new color Ams every time and not show traits of other birds or colors used to make them anymore they are breeding true and can get recognition as that breed AND new color for standards.) That is why I said that the first few generations of a really good breeder are EE not Ams. They become Ams again through that selective breeding that eliminates traits-- getting back to SOP again folks

I hope other people can see how this is confusing to a new person coming in if you can't follow what I am saying. I am saying it as clear as I think I can.
AmxAm= Am period
Amx other chicken breeds= EE
NS AmxAm=Am or NS Am This is where judging comes in.
I'm saying a NS Am isn't an EE. EE should only be about the breed and not about standards. Any better??