I am interested in establishing a flock that has the potential to produce show quality birds but will at the very least produce birds that breed true to standards. I like larger birds and egg color is very important to me. I want to be confident that if I sell hatching eggs or chicks to someone down the line they will get exactly what they were expecting and not have to deal with all the difficulties that I have to work through.
I also have 3 blue wheaten pullets and 1 wheaten pullet. They are from two different breeders, 1 well known for the egg color of her birds and the other one a random seller on BYC. I just started getting eggs from these pullets and two are on the green side even though they were hatched from decent eggs. One of the eggs from the other two pullets is beautiful; B6 in color and a beautiful shape (this is from the "well known" breeder and I will definitely keep her but am not sure which one laid it. My question is regarding one of the pullets that laid a greenish egg. She is beautiful, very large - my best blue wheaten pullet from a form standpoint in my opinion (will send picture). My issues are with egg color and that the other pullets from that breeder have varying degrees of curled toes (inbreeding?). She does not. Is it worth trying to breed to a better egg color or should I just move on from her.
Sorry about the long post but I just wanted to share my experience and get some general comments from the board. I could never have imagined just how difficult it would be to build a halfway decent flock of chickens when I stated out so innocently last year .
John
A couple of quick observations and comments for the benefit of all hands. I sent you a PM and addresses some other things as well.
First, you have a very worthy goal when you say, "I want to be confident that if I sell hatching eggs or chicks to someone down the line they will get exactly what they were expecting and not have to deal with all the difficulties that I have to work through." However, you should expect to work years in order to achieve that goal. Until you find yourself getting 75-90% of your chicks all turning out the same, you can't expect others will.
Which bring me to my second point with regard to your comment, "I could never have imagined just how difficult it would be to build a halfway decent flock of chickens when I stated out so innocently last year." I think many of us may be guilty of inadvertently and unknowingly leading others to believe that this idea of breeding chickesn to a SOP is a quick process and that all one has to do is buy eggs or chicks from some top breeder in the country and Voila - now you've got some too. Everyone should be aware that it's just not that simple.
As I told John in my PM, I raised 100 chicks this year from each of my four breeds and I only kept about 4 or so of each breed. Now I fully realize that some of the chicks I sold may be show quality birds and, could in fact, wind up beating my birds at a show. But for those old enough for me to judge, I kept the best. That being said, I have no doubt that a good 50% or so of my birds would not be show worthy. Some plain out had DQ's. Others had severe (or least what I'd consider severe) faults. Of the remaining 50%, most of those is where my birds were 2-3 years ago. So I have no need of them but they would make good "starting" stock for many.
And "starting stock" is what needs to be looked at. Those just getting into a breed and desiring to breed for show, should not expect to start out with the best. Besides that, what pleasure is that? Taking someone else's efforts and winning a show would mean little to me. So I maintain that beginners should not set their expectations too high. Start with a worthy goal and work to improve each year. That's my two-cents.
As for the BW gal that lays the blue egg, if you go back and look thru this thread you will find I've written on this subject fairly extensively. Most of my W's & BW's laid a green egg when I started out. Now I'm not sure I have any that do. Certainly not the two that are laying now. With a good linebreeding program, the brown egg gene modifiers can be eliminated.
God Bless,
Royce