Cross-posted from the "Real Ameraucana Group" on Facebook... While I'm thinking about it

, let's talk about another question that comes up frequently and is equally difficult to answer. "Is this bird an Ameraucana?" Sometimes, it is easy to tell and a quick answer will often follow. However, I have to remind myself that there are two major criteria to a pure bred..anything - chicken, dog, horse, lizard, etc. Does it look like whatever it should be look like AND Will it breed true? In other words, looking at a picture of a bird is not sufficient information to tell if it is a true Ameraucana. Without knowing what it's parentage was, or what it has already produced - the answer can only be based on appearances. And, we all know that appearances can be deceiving. A couple of years ago - and a few still last year - I was all into purposefully creating Easter Eggers and Olive Eggers. By the time I decided to focus strictly on my real Ameraucanas, I had some second and third generation EEs and OEs. If I had been so inclined, I could have sold some of those OE pullets as pure brown red Ameraucanas to the unsuspecting! Their appearance, especially to those less versed in the Ameraucana SOP, was very close to what a nice brown red pullet should look like. Of course, they would never have bred true - too much garbage in their ancestry that would come out sooner or later. But if I had posted a picture of one of them here and asked, "is this a true Ameraucana?", there are many, based on appearance alone, that would have said yes. Again, I don't want to stop the questions, I just want us all to think about our answers.

Including me, I've been guilty of it myself. In order to give a qualified answer, there needs to be more information - where did the bird come from? What is it's parentage? Has it produced and what were the results? From the responses to those questions, someone can start to give a responsible answer. First of all, if it came from a hatchery - even those that say they are selling "Ameraucanas" - you probably have an EE...or a very poor specimen of Ameraucana, in a few very rare cases. If the person selling the bird says it is an "AmerIcana", then it is an EE. If the person selling the bird says it is an Ameraucana, but can't specify which variety - chances are it is an EE.