Ameraucana vs EE question

[mct01]

I returned 2 Faverolles that turned out to be boys Saturday. Thanks to the help from everyone letting me know they were boys. In the process of swapping the Faverolles I thought I might as well get a few more. Bought 2 that she said we're Ameraucana. Reading about them I see that the Ameraucana is from breeders and it could be a EE. I really don't care either way. She buys eggs, hatches and sells the chicks. One is white and the other is blue. Here is a picture. She mentioned the leg color. Anyway here they are with the Faverolles. Around 5 weeks. Thanks for looking.

 

[Lady of McCamley]

I'm sorry but it is best to have individual, close up photos of each bird to give our best estimation.

From what I'm seeing in the group shot, nobody is an Ameraucana as no one looks to have muffed cheeks.

The blue bird looks to have a pea comb, but the leg color is wrong, and no muffed cheeks...other than maybe a slight fluff in one photo??? But not what I would expect from an Ameraucana.

The white bird ditto...although I can't really see its leg color....but it doesn't have muffed cheeks.

So from this photo shot, I would assume they are Easter Eggers.

LofMc

you can see what I mean here:
http://ameraucanabreedersclub.org/gallery.html

 

[drumstick diva]

x 2

 

[ChattyChickens4Life]

I agree that we need individual photos to better assess the characteristics of each bird. But I can give it a shot. I have 4 EEs right now, and the all white one looks just like my Snowy EE, Muffin. I can sort of see her legs, and it looks like the bluish-brown color you get from an EE. As for the other one, I'm not sure. I need a close up photo. Best wishes!

-Chatty


Here is my Snowy EE, Muffin at about 4 weeks old.

 

[mct01]

Thanks. I will pull my good camera out and get better pictures.