I pay $3.50 for a dozen when my hens don't lay enough (like this month, egg demand was MUCH higher than supply due to the holiday.) Free range eggs in the grocery store go for about $4 I think (I don't buy them. If I have to buy eggs at the grocery store, I'll buy the $1 white eggs. Free range is a marketing ploy, doesn't mean they actually treat their chickens any better.) I paid $4/dz in IN before we moved here to NC 2 years ago.