I am liking this thread really well! I was raised Methodist but my family and I were "not settled" on a church that we would be comfortable to listen to sermons. However for ME, it did not satisfy my inner need and I do not like to be questioned about how strong my faith is toward Jesus or some kind of "test" to see if you have fallen flat on your face and you must make your mistakes known. Nor would I like to be judged as "Judas" either and they would tell me to "choose my friends or else, you would go to hell" type of thing. Sorry, it just don't work with me.
I do believe in a higher sense, like God but I do believe in science as well....like how the earth is created. The Bible only probably a thousand years or less old when it was first written by one of Jesus' discliples. However somewhere down the line, the "missing" books and chapters were omitted by the scholars, "it was too long" to read.
I do not know what I call myself when I do believe in spirits, inner soul, treat someone like you want to be treated, know when you did something wrong, that it can bite you back later down the line, moral judgements and conscepts and believe there ARE dinosaurs, strange creatures in the deep sea, unknown to mankind, the carbon datings of things we wanted to know how old Earth is and how things have evolve from one point to another, either by a fluke or man's hand in breeding or genetics played a role in it.
So what do I call myself? I don't think it would call myself athetic because I still believe in "higher sense of being, greater than man" out there and the burning question "Is there a God?" That is a very hard question to ask. Also there is evolution, Darwinism kind of things that I believe that we MIGHT have "off shoots" of the apes, the odd kind of a genetic fluke that both chimp parents having a lesser haired, walking more upright (remember Lucy?).