i think i would go with the wrapping the bird in burlap & decapitating considering the info shared here. 5 min to die is way too long for me, even if it means less effective bleed out, i think i would go for quick. but i am intriqued by the idea of raising geese.
if geese are hard to put up at night, what is it that they prefer? are they wanting to stay out all night? my chicks (6 wks old) are still afraid of the dark. they head for the coop pretty quick in the evening.
mine aren't particularly hard to put up at night, and often will put themselves up, as will my ducks. when they are busy playing and don't want to go up, a small scoop of corn solves the problem, and basic herding skills work well with geese... I've got a post on here a while back where I covered all you need to know to herd ducks and geese, I'll dig it up if you're interested.
the basic routine for getting geese (or ducks) to go up easily at night is this:
1) pen them in the intended night-pen for a week or two so they know where they live
2) always feed them inside their night pen
3) feed at night, not in the morning - give them a happy reason to go in the pen at night
4) maintain proper respect from them... don't let them dominate you or you won't be able to herd them when needed
5) practice herding them at other times (besides bed time) so they - and you - learn to do the herding thing separate from bedtime
6) put them up every night, no exceptions
7) expect them to test you from time to time, especially at the beginning of breeding season, or when they enter breeding age... don't let them get anything by you, testing will stop if you're consistant in managing them
anyway, that's what we've done successfully with quite a few batches of ducks and geese, and the more we stick with the program, the better it works. if you skip any of the parts (we have sometimes) it will mean you occasionally have to work a little harder to put them up, but overall, we don't struggle with them at all.
we've mostly kept african or chinese geese (white or brown) and they're pretty loud, pretty bossy, somewhat excitable, so not the easiest of geese to work with.
what do they prefer? out all night partying!
mine are as active at night as during the day, they'll nap some, then putter about some. if they have the option, they'll be back and forth from the pond to the hutch at least a dozen times a night. and if it's rained and there are mudpuddles... well they'll dabble in those all night long.