Are you an ethical person?

We've got a local who keeps posting birds for sale on Craigslist and using pictures from Feathersite instead of showing his/her own birds. I emailed them about it and now they're giving credit to Feathersite. Still bugs me though.

Kathy, Bellville TX
www.CountryChickens.com
 
Quote:
I agree the whole "ethics" thing goes alot further and/or deeper.

If a clerk at the store gives you to much change back?
You bump somebodies car in a parking lot?

smile.png


Steve
 
Personally...I think it is wrong to do so without the owner's permission however legally, if it is not copyrighted it is fair game unless there is some posted language on the site stating you cannot use them.

I would not do it knowingly.
 
You have to be true to yourself.

If I get too much change back at the store, I say something, because if I get shorted, I am going to squawk about it. Fair is fair.
 
but you can dye an ENTIRE horse black?
She dyes his white socks and light brown muzzle black and I must say she does a very good job, hardly anybody has figured it out except those who saw him as a foal

Where is the sense in that?
To make him appear something he is not, such as, he has the homozygous gene (E+E+) that passes pure black

Why she actually does it? I don't know. I don't associate with unethical people.
 
My understanding of the law on this is fuzzy, so I'll just address the ethical aspect.

I think people have a poor understanding, in general, of exactly what is wrong with plagiarizing. These are probably people who thought nothing of finding someone else's book report or term paper on the internet and handing it in as their own when they were in school.

When you take the product of someone else's creativity and labor and claim it as your own-- writing or images-- you're misrepresenting yourself and doing a discredit to the person whose work you're ripping off. Personally, I don't see a problem with presenting someone else's work if you attribute it as such, and in fact many people find it highly gratifying to see themselves quoted by others or their work shown off by someone else....so long as that "someone else" isn't pretending it's their own or profiting off of it.

I have written articles, essays, and two theses and would be absolutely livid to find out that somebody had copied from them and claimed it as their own. Sorry if you're feeling to lazy to write that final essay for your college course-- that doesn't make the product of my long hours of research fair game.
 
"... legally, if it is not copyrighted it is fair game unless there is some posted language on the site stating you cannot use them."

I'm not an attorney, but it is my understanding that all intellectual property is "copyrighted" (legally yours) the moment you create it. Using a copyright symbol or having it registered with the copyright office are not necessary, though the copyright symbol may in some cases deter people.

ETA: I never answered the original question. Yes, I believe it is unethical to take someone else's work without permission.
 
Last edited:
Quote:
That is correct. The reason some people still file with the copyright office is to make it easier to defend their copyright in court. And larger companies sometimes do it because the copyrighted document contains trademarks that they want to prove are in use.

Kathy, Bellville TX
www.CountryChickens.com
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom