Quote:
First, in my opinion, birds can't be judged from pictures. Pictures just don't do the bird justice. Colors cannot be distinguished due to poor lighting or shadows. Feathers look distorted or rough due to wind or the condition of the coop floor...It just isn't fair to make a decision or formulate an opinion from a picture...JMO
...so second point....Is your rooster a little too red ?...or is it a camera trick...Maybe his comb isn't exactly perfect?...again a poor camera angle could distort the perfect bird....Is the overall feather condition a little loose?...or is there just a breeze...I really can't see the lacing at all which would be another important fact but needs to be viewed close up with a wing spread...Is the lacing pattern irregular? Or is it just a shadow....
My opinion " they are definitely Barnevelders"...but that is the only fact I could be sure of without holding one of them in my hands...Again JMO