Thank you.
Reasons I think Pip is a pullet:
Mt Healthy says the extra will be the same gender/breed as what you ordered. (Biel pullet) She certainly looked like the other three. This is the 4 together, at a few days old.
View attachment 3560362
Someone said she had skinny, girly legs, and they aren't any chunkier than the other three. They still aren't noticeably chunkier.
Reasons I fear Pip is a cockerel:
Comb size.
Tidbitting behavior recently.
Reasons I am on the fence:
I can't do anything about it!