Thanks for the replies, they're helpful. So is it correct to say that mahogany is too dark and straw is too light? If so, here's a question: what if someone only had mahogany and straw to choose from in their flock for breeding stock, which would someone choose? Or would they want to use some of both in hopes of getting the right color in future generations? I don't think that's my situation, but I'm curious. BTW, I have no plans to sell chicks, these are just our backyard flock. I just like to think that things worth doing, are worth doing right.