#2 They both have some red on the chest... the standard says parsimonious and some will say it should be all black.(American Standard). but I like them both about equally. The color is a little varied in both of them (some refer to it as color banance) but otherwise they look pretty good for a first crack. (I think). Someone said keep them both which is not bad but maybe since you only have two hens, you could trade one for another hen. If I had to choose I like number 2 but they are both pretty good looking birds. 2 looks bigger. The pics of 1 don't show his comb very well. HF.