Hi Kelly,
I am hoping that some of the folks on here have experience with both breeds. My experience is limited to several weeks of laying by my two Ark blue egg layers and I would love to see an objective comparison between the two breeds. My birds have only laying for a few weeks and I am now getting 2 eggs a day from them. The eggs are perfectly shaped and a nice color. Right now they are still on the small side... 1.5-1.6 oz. they started out at 1.0 oz so they are getting bigger. I've heard of eggs in large to xtra large range maybe bigger but someone would have to confirm that. These birds will be definite keepers if they continue to lay the way they are and produce xtra large eggs. As for the SFHs I agree and decided on them over speckled Sussex. The eggs are larger , the birds are stunning and hopefully won't be as broody as the Sussex. I had two Mille fleur patterned SFHs just at point of lay that got cocci a few weeks ago and died before I realized what was going on . I tried to get more eggs but am going to have to wait until spring. I am so bummed
Thank you for the comparison!
I think the Blues are nicer looking but I am partial to Blue Breeds.