I agree if your wanting a breeding rooster for your Orps you need to wait a good while longer. I really think the Splash is going to turn out nice and the dark blue...It would be between those two for me.
I also have a really really nice black that I wasn't even considering keeping just because I figured I get a better selection of blues and splashes if I didn't use him. Would you recommend I reconsider letting him go??
Have you posted a pic of him? I'm trying to keep one of each color personally for my own use..
I have an older Blue now that gets along with the Black younger roo so I keep them together during the year...I have a new Splash cockeral growing out...
Black over blue hens will give you 50% blacks & 50% Blues...
They are all beautiful! They are slow growing and it would be wise to wait somewhere between six to eight months before you make your decision. I agree with the folks in here...just wait and see!