I cannot concur more. Two year ago I used primarily natural incubation with positive results; indeed, the years prior I had used artificial incubation. The year of natural incubation produced stronger results. With this in mind, last year I used all artificial incubation...because I'm just smart that way
. The results were noticibly down from the natural incubation year. This coming year, we've saved a couple dozen White Dorking cull pullets to serve as broodies. Barring on special project, the natural of which makes artificila incubation the more practical, we shall be using only natural incubation. On a certain level it's a bit more work, filling more waterers and feeder, etc... However, the broodies just do a better job.
- Firstly, they keep the peace. With broodies we don't have pecking issues whatsoever; everyone grows up with a tail.
- I never see pasty-butt.
- There's the possibility of higher immunity.
- Then there's the reality of much lower electric bulbs. Eight to ten 250 watt bulbs plus four incubators costs a handsome chunk of change. For the work of extra waters and the needed original investment in infrastructure, it's a nice savings.
- They learn to roost at the appropriate time. I've found that it takes our Dorkings far too long to learn to roost, if they don't have a broody showing them what's for.
- I never have to worry about power shortages. Climate change and luck of the Irish has brought about regular power outages around here right in the middle of hatching season. With broodies I don't have to worry. Once I was up 48 hours straight keeping the wood in the wood stove up enough to keep way too many chicks warm in metal livestock drinking tubs nestled close to the furnace.
- They can be allowed to free-range earlier because the broody will bring them back to roost. Otherwise they often don't know enough to return, and, if the Dorkings are taking too long to learn to roost, that leads to one big pain in the neck.
- When they are on free-range they're safer in that mom doubles as a watchdog.
All in all, I'm happier with the hens. Can anyone add to this list?
On the APA website one can buy for a meager sum a compendium of black and white Schilling photos. I have it, and enjoy it. It doesn't have as many birds represented, but it's nice.