Before people begin fantasizing about heritage birds and breeding them, let's take a moment for a reality check. It seems the beginners who live in the city, who are limited, by ordinance, to 6 hens, allowed no roosters, who have only had chickens in their bathroom or backyard tiny coopette for just a few weeks, ought to really master the whole keeping of birds first. I'm trying to say here what needs to be said, not necessarily what folks want to hear.
Use some hatchery grade hens to practice on. Get used to raising out chicks, integrating birds, living with them for a few years and experience the entire cycle for a couple of years. Feeding, coop cleaning, life, death, euthanizing, disease, the whole deal. If you succeed with those hatchery birds and still want to do this in two years, great. Until then?
Sell your city house and buy yourself a place in the country where you really can breed quality birds, keep crowing roosters, learn all about rooster behaviors up close and personal, build multiple coops, pens and barns. Meanwhile, sit in on some local breed club meetings. Go to regional APA sanctioned poultry shows, look at the fancy birds, submit to a mentor, meet some people, and spend a whole lot of time as a student and spend a lot more time just listening.
Otherwise, this is all just an internet fantasy.
Good points. A little dose of reality is of value.
I think the fantasy you refer to persists because people are told that certain breeds are "at risk," some critically, etc. Everyone wants to help save a breed and genetic material. That's a noble thing. Truly. And there are "authorities" out there telling us that anyone can help save a breed, which ends up including those who don't own any roosters.
Do you think that maybe there are different levels of participation? Without any certain level being necessarily a better level of participation that the others, but maybe some levels can get more accomplished? For instance, one who will keep roosters and breed a hundred or more chicks a year, raise them up to so many months, pick their five to add to the breeding group ... this participant will get more accomplished toward keeping the standard.
Another participant who is willing to breed to the SOP
and sell eggs or chicks will be working on another portion of the process of breed preservation, which is getting chicks into the hands of people who just want some eggs and will enjoy and promote the breed just because they own a few.
Still another participant in the preservation of the breed will be that person mentioned above that will buy chicks from breeders of heritage breeds. It takes a little bit of effort to find a breeder (as opposed to propagator) sometimes, but buying chicks from her/him supports that breeder's efforts to preserve the breed and is, therefore, ultimately helping to preserve the breed.
Anyway. I don't have the answers. I'm just thinking out loud. If there are different levels of participation in heritage breed bird preservation (ALBC preservation), then I fall in the group that just buys a few from breeders. I don't end up with many heritage breed chickens for various reasons, but I have a few and I enjoy them. Of course, I look for ones that lay eggs because I keep chickens for their eggs. (I have some non-ALBC heritage breeds (as in old type of chicken, but not APA) that I've been keeping, but they, of course, don't count here.)
What do you think, Fred's Hens, (or anyone, I guess), you wrote: "Use some hatchery grade hens to practice on." Do you think it's necessary that one use hatchery grade birds to practice on? What if a person got some good (not superlative) breeder quality chicks and practiced on those? (If money isn't an issue for the buyer. And whatever the breeder was willing to part with.)
After two years you suggest, if any hens are still alive and maybe one looks especially promising, maybe it could be used to breed from with a newly bought rooster? That hen will have proven herself longevity wise and might possibly already have a good laying record if records were kept. If fifty chicks were hatched out of her maybe one or two would be great? You know how that can work. The genetics would be there as a possibility because she'd be a heritage chicken from a breeder. Couldn't this be a way for the owner of the little backyard flock that has newly moved to the country to have a head start on a heritage flock. Maybe? Your thoughts?