Whoa, ChanceRider, what a freaky story! A creature that unafraid of a human sounds very dangerous. I live on an island where the largest predators are the sailors from the naval base close by, LOL. I don't suppose they'll be stealing my chickens anytime soon though.
We do have coyotes around my place, and I too have lost two hens with not a sound, feather, or drop of blood. No footprints, no trace at all. The only reason I even suspect coyote is that I saw a large one skulking around the perimeter of my huge yard the same day the two hens didn't come home.
Oddly, out of the 20 hens free-ranging that morning, the only two taken were the only two who happened to be laying eggs.
As if it wasn't bad enough to lose the hens.
Hope you can figure out what's getting your girls and keep them away from here on out.
We do have coyotes around my place, and I too have lost two hens with not a sound, feather, or drop of blood. No footprints, no trace at all. The only reason I even suspect coyote is that I saw a large one skulking around the perimeter of my huge yard the same day the two hens didn't come home.
Oddly, out of the 20 hens free-ranging that morning, the only two taken were the only two who happened to be laying eggs.

Hope you can figure out what's getting your girls and keep them away from here on out.