THank you for taking the time to share--- I totally agree with you, on all points. lol@Arielle
Finding a new breed can be very daunting and frustrating. Be patient, you will know when you find it. Then be patient again in finding just the right breeder. It takes time to establish and develop relationships and to gain knowledge about who the reputable breeders are. Listen carefully to what the experienced breeders of other breeds have to say. There is frequently as much wisdom in what they don't say as in what they do. ;-)
I personally avoid (boy, I may offend a few folks here but here goes), anyone who has lots of breeds. If someone has 10, 15 or even more breeds then I have trouble wrapping my head around how they can possibly be doing each breed justice. I'm not talking about backyard chickens or laying flocks. I'm talking about people who sell eggs and/or chicks that are a specific "breed" who have more than a couple of breeds.
Find someone who cares enough to point you in the right direction of a few good mentors - good mentors are like lgds... they are invaluable. ;-)
I have 26 buckeye chicks that arrived vigorous and ready to eat. all healthy and no losses. I credit this to two factors--plenty of experience raising chicks, and good stock. I picked this breeder for many of the points you listed. Has only2 breeds; been at it a few years, available for questions.
While the buckeye are a winter layer, this line is the closest I could get in a non- single comb breed. When I asked Laura Haggertyabout the laying, I was slightly disappointed in the time frame. I would like more eggs for Oct - Dec.
I did read of a few breeders that had good stock that only missed about 3 weeks, butwith single combs, that is a no go, at least for the roosters. Hopefully with more experience I can determine a method to manage the roosters
One of the SS cckls lost ALL his points, and it makes him look rather ominous-- like a true raptor of ancient times. lol I didn't cull him because of his comb-- he had good muscling so he stays-- after all not many points for a comb. lol
SaddlyI mayonly find what I am looking for in a commercial layer.